Market Moments

NAR Settlement and Real Estate Teams: What Agents Want From a Team Now

The rules changed one conversation every buyer agent has to have. Here is what that did to the reasons agents choose a team, and what to build because of it.
Blake Suddath By Blake Suddath  ·  November 21, 2026

For about a year, everybody in real estate argued about the NAR settlement.

Commissions would collapse. Buyer agents would disappear. Half the industry would quit.

Most of that did not happen.

But something did change, and if you recruit agents you should pay attention to it. What the NAR settlement did to real estate teams was quieter than the headlines. It changed the first conversation an agent has with a buyer. And that changed what agents look for when they decide who to work with.

I am Blake Suddath, a real estate recruiter and recruiting coach and the co-founder of Inner Cirql Recruiting Systems with Tyler Lewis. This post covers what the settlement changed, what it left alone, and what agents now want from a team.

One note first. I am a recruiter, not a lawyer. For the rules in your state, talk to your broker and your state association.

The Rules

What the NAR Settlement Changed for Real Estate Teams

Start with what happened.

On March 15, 2024, HousingWire reported that the National Association of Realtors had agreed to pay $418 million to settle the commission lawsuits brought by home sellers. Real Estate News reported the same figure.

The money made the headlines. The rule changes are what reached your agents. Real Estate News described two at the core of the deal: offers of compensation came off the MLS, and buyer agreements became a requirement.

NAR's own guide for buyers and sellers says the practice changes went into effect on August 17, 2024. Real Estate News reported the same date. Since then, agents who use an MLS have to enter into a written agreement with a buyer before touring a home. According to NAR, that agreement has to state, specifically and conspicuously, the amount or rate the agent will be paid, or how it will be determined.

The second change is about where pay gets discussed. NAR says offers of compensation are no longer allowed on the MLS, though sellers can still offer compensation off the MLS.

Now read those two rules the way an agent does.

The first one means an agent has to talk about what they cost, in writing, before the first showing. The second means the buyer agent's pay is no longer sitting in a field on the listing. It has to be asked for and agreed to.

That is a conversation a lot of agents had never been asked to have.

The Numbers

What the Settlement Did Not Change

The big prediction was that commissions would fall.

So far, on average, they have not. A Redfin analysis found the average buyer's agent commission was 2.42% in the third quarter of 2025. A year earlier it was 2.36%. Both HousingWire and Real Estate News reported those numbers on December 8, 2025.

Read that again. More than a year after the rules took effect, the average was slightly UP.

Real Estate News looked at the first full year of the rules in August 2025 and reported that sellers were still paying the buyer's agent for the most part. It also raised a fair question: what happens when the market swings back toward sellers? Nobody knows yet.

The same article named what did change in year one. Buyer agreements were being signed earlier, and more conversations about commission were taking place.

That is the real story. The pay mostly held. The conversation changed.

And when the conversation changes, the skill an agent needs changes with it.

The Shift

What Agents Want From a Team After the NAR Settlement

This part is my read from recruiting and coaching agents. It is not a published study, so weigh it that way.

Before August 2024, an agent could go years without explaining a fee to a buyer. Now every buyer relationship starts there. Some agents handle it well. Plenty of good agents do not have the words yet.

When an agent feels shaky in a conversation they have every week, they start looking around. Not for a better split. For someone who can make them better at it.

Here is what I think agents need now.

The words. What do I say when a buyer asks why they have to sign something before seeing a house? What do I say when they ask what I cost? Agents do not want a script to read out loud. They want a way to explain their value that they believe.

A place to practice. Nobody wants to try a new conversation for the first time in front of a live buyer. Agents want reps in a room where it is safe to get it wrong.

A leader who backs them up. When a buyer pushes back, or a deal gets tense over who is paying whom, an agent wants someone to call who has been there.

Notice what is not on that list. A bigger split. More leads.

Those still matter, and I covered how to think about them in real estate team split structure for recruiting. But a split does not help an agent who freezes when a buyer asks about the fee.

I learned a version of this the hard way. I handed agents leads and thought that was support. "They don't know how to set an appointment." "They don't know what to say on the phone." "And I never showed them."

Leads without the words is not help. The settlement just made that easier to see.

Recruiting

What This Means for Your Recruiting Conversation

Every agent you are recruiting is quietly asking one question. Will this team make me better at the conversations I have to have now?

Most team leaders answer a different question. They talk about the split, the leads and the tech.

I said this on a call: "You are the value proposition." It was true before the settlement. It is easier to prove now, because the thing agents need most is something only a leader and a team can give them. I went deeper on this in real estate team value proposition.

So change the first call.

Ask about their buyer conversations. How has the buyer agreement been going for you? Then stop talking. You will learn more about that agent in the next five minutes than a production report will tell you. The full first meeting is laid out in the first real estate recruiting appointment.

Show, do not tell. Do not describe your training. Invite the agent to watch it. More on that in the next section.

Leave their broker out of it. If their current brokerage did not train them for this, they already know. You do not need to say it. I wrote about that in how to recruit agents without trashing their broker.

One more thing. I said on a coaching call, "I think the best recruiter is the best communicator." The same is true for agents now. The rules made clear communication a bigger part of the job. A team that teaches it has something real to offer an experienced agent, not just a new one. If experienced agents are who you are after, read how to recruit experienced real estate agents.

Training

Build the Training Into the Week

A one-time class in August 2024 was not training. It was a compliance update.

Training is what happens every week.

Use ten minutes of your weekly meeting. One agent plays the buyer. One agent explains the agreement and what they charge. The room listens and helps. Rotate who goes. Ten minutes a week adds up to a team that does not flinch.

Review a real one in the one-on-one. Ask each agent about a buyer conversation from that week. What did the buyer ask? What did you say? What would you say next time?

Start new hires on it right away. In an agent's first 30 days, sit in on a buyer consultation or run one together. The rest of that first month is in onboarding experienced real estate agents.

Let recruits watch. I have written before about saving guests a seat in the back of the weekly meeting, in real estate recruiting events. When a guest watches your agents practice the exact conversation she is nervous about, you do not need a pitch.

This is how I built what we teach in the first place. "I would just get better and learn more and solve each agent's problem of what they felt like they needed." The problem agents feel right now is this conversation. So solve it.

It pays off in recruiting too. Of the 115 agents we hired in 2025, 78 were referred by producing agents we had recruited. Agents do not send friends to a team that left them on their own.

And it keeps people. "Human beings leave other human beings. To be led. By other human beings." An agent who gets better every week in your room has a reason to stay in it. The rest of that is in real estate agent retention.

If you want to see your training the way a recruit sees it, TheInnerCirql.com has a guide written for agents on how to judge a real estate agent training program. Hold your own team up to it.

Systems

Where AI and Systems Fit

None of this works from memory.

When a recruit tells you the buyer agreement conversation has been hard, write it down in your CRM that day. In her words. Then your follow-up can be useful: an invitation to the meeting where you practice it, not another check-in message.

AI helps around the edges. It can write practice scenarios for your meeting. It can turn your notes into a one-page guide for new agents. It can remind you which recruits you have not talked to in 30 days.

It cannot sit across from a buyer and explain what an agent is worth. And it should not write the agreement. That comes from your broker's approved forms.

This is why we pair recruiting with training in the Territory Takeover System. The Always-On Agent System gives new hires coaching, follow-up systems and AI training from their first week, so the offer you make in the recruiting conversation is one the team keeps. The funnel behind our 2025 hires is in real estate recruiting benchmarks.

For the dates, the rules and the commission data in one place, see the reference page on how the NAR settlement changed real estate teams. And for the wider picture of why agents say no, there is the reference page on why agents turn down team offers.

Summary

The Bottom Line

The NAR settlement did not end buyer agency, and so far it has not cut the average commission. It changed one conversation, and it made that conversation required.

Agents now need the words, the practice and a leader behind them. That is what they want from a team.

Teach it every week. Let recruits watch. Then your offer is not a split. It is a room that makes agents better.

Want a team agents choose for the training?

One call covers your recruiting conversation, your weekly training rhythm and whether the Territory Takeover System fits your market.

Schedule Your Call
FAQ

FAQ

How did the NAR settlement change real estate teams?

The NAR settlement changed real estate teams by changing the first conversation every buyer agent has to have. According to NAR, since August 17, 2024, agents who use an MLS must have a written agreement with a buyer before touring a home, and that agreement must spell out what the agent will be paid. Offers of compensation also came off the MLS. Agents now need training and practice for that conversation, so the teams that teach it have a stronger offer than the teams that only talk about splits and leads.

When did the NAR settlement rules take effect?

The practice changes took effect on August 17, 2024, according to NAR and Real Estate News. HousingWire reported on March 15, 2024 that NAR had agreed to pay $418 million to settle the commission lawsuits brought by home sellers. The two changes agents felt most were the written buyer agreement before touring a home and the removal of offers of compensation from the MLS. State rules can differ, so check with your broker and your state association.

Did the NAR settlement lower buyer agent commissions?

Not on average, based on the data so far. A Redfin analysis found the average buyer's agent commission was 2.42% in the third quarter of 2025, up from 2.36% a year earlier, according to HousingWire and Real Estate News on December 8, 2025. Real Estate News also reported that sellers were still paying the buyer's agent in most cases a year after the rules took effect. That could change if the market shifts toward sellers, which is one more reason agents need to be able to explain their value.

What do agents want from a team after the NAR settlement?

Agents want help with the conversation the rules now require. Since August 17, 2024, according to NAR, a buyer has to sign a written agreement that states the agent's pay before touring a home. My read, from recruiting and coaching, is that it pushed three things up the list: the words to explain their value, a place to practice, and a leader who backs them up when a buyer pushes back. Splits and leads still matter, but they do not fix a conversation an agent is nervous about.

How should team leaders recruit after the NAR settlement?

Team leaders should recruit by asking about the agent's buyer conversations and showing how the team trains for them. Real Estate News reported that the biggest changes in the first year of the rules were that buyer agreements are signed earlier and more commission conversations are taking place. So ask how those conversations are going, listen, and invite the agent to a weekly meeting where your team practices them. Do not lead with the split. Lead with how you make agents better.

Can AI help agents with buyer agreement conversations?

AI can help agents prepare for buyer agreement conversations, but it cannot have them. It can write practice scenarios, turn your meeting notes into a one-page guide and remind you to follow up with a recruit who said she was struggling with it. The agreement itself, which NAR says must be in writing before a buyer tours a home, should come from your broker's approved forms. The conversation with the buyer still has to come from the agent.

Blake Suddath is a real estate recruiter and recruiting coach who has recruited over 400 real estate agents since September 2019 and coached more than 1,000 since 2020. He co-founded Inner Cirql Recruiting Systems with Tyler Lewis and helps team leaders and broker owners build teams agents choose for the training through the Territory Takeover System. The quotes from Blake in this post are his own, from recorded calls and his own written words. This post is not legal advice.